Florida sheriffs rarely turn against Republican governors.
They just did – and now the governor's signature ballot measure is polling 15 points below the threshold it needs to survive.
Ron DeSantis just told a crowd in Alabama he doesn't think Amendment 3 is going to make it – and the reason why should make every conservative in Florida furious.
The Governor Called for Cutting Police Budgets to Defend a Tax Plan He Already Admitted Was Gutted
The Florida Sheriffs Association came out against Amendment 3.
So did the Florida State Fraternal Order of Police – representing 24,000 officers across the state.
So did the Florida Professional Firefighters.
So did the Florida Fire Chiefs Association.
https://twitter.com/ReOpenChris/status/2100697274728817014?s=20
Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd warned the amendment could "devastate counties' and cities' ability to deliver vital services."
Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri put it more bluntly: "There's no plan."
DeSantis' response to every one of those sheriffs was to suggest their budgets probably have room to be cut.
Read that again.
A Republican governor told Florida's law enforcement community to accept budget cuts – so he could defend a tax plan the Legislature had already stripped down to something he didn't even want.
DeSantis' original proposal covered school levies under the exemption increase and included a trust fund to protect fiscally constrained counties from absorbing the revenue loss.
The Legislature removed both provisions.
DeSantis initially said he wouldn't campaign for the watered-down version, then reversed in August.
Now he's at the University of Alabama's Shelby Institute admitting the whole thing is probably dead.
"I don't know if it's going to pass with 60%," he said. "I wanted to be bolder and I thought that would bring out more voters who maybe aren't enthused about voting."
The latest St. Pete Polls survey puts Amendment 3 at 45% – 15 points short of the supermajority Florida requires for constitutional amendments to pass.
The research arm of the Florida Legislature estimated the amendment would cut property tax revenue by as much as $12 billion annually.
https://twitter.com/ReOpenChris/status/2100690926876365143?s=20
No one has identified where that money comes from to keep patrol cars on the road and firehouses open.
That silence is exactly why the sheriffs walked.
Grady Judd Opposed It and Republican Voters Took Notice
Amendment 3 hits 60% with exactly one group in the St. Pete Polls survey: Republicans – at 63%.
Barely.
Independents are at 40%, nowhere near the threshold.
Democrats oppose it 48% to 24%.
When Grady Judd tells conservative Florida homeowners their sheriff's response times are going to get longer, they listen.
When the Fraternal Order of Police tells 24,000 members to vote no, those members have families and neighbors.
When the governor responds by suggesting law enforcement budgets can absorb cuts, the coalition he spent years building starts doing the math.
The same St. Pete Polls survey shows the Florida governor's race, U.S. Senate race, and attorney general's race are all too close to call – in a state where Republicans now hold a 1.5 million voter registration advantage.
DeSantis saw it coming.
At the Shelby Institute, he said Republican voter morale is "very low" heading into the midterm – and he named exactly why.
"The Republicans run on reducing spending, limiting government and shrinking it – and they never do it," he said. "They sign off on all these massive spending bills. So there's a dichotomy between what they're telling the voters and what they actually do once they get up there."
He's describing himself as much as Congress.
DeSantis promised Floridians a bold property tax overhaul, delivered a compromise bill stripped of its strongest provisions, with no revenue replacement plan, and opposed by the entire law enforcement community.
Conservative voters don't stay home because Democrats are winning arguments.
They stay home because their own party keeps making promises and delivering excuses.
When Grady Judd – a man who has stood next to Republican governors at press conference after press conference – tells Florida voters this plan will hurt them, that's not a political calculation.
That's the coalition telling a governor he went too far in the wrong direction.
Sources:
- A.G. Gancarski, "Ron DeSantis doubts Amendment 3 will hit 60% after poll puts it at 45%," Florida Politics, September 18, 2026.
- Ballotpedia, "Florida voters to decide expanded homestead tax exemption amendment in November," Ballotpedia, June 3, 2026.
- "Florida Sheriffs Association is 'significantly concerned' about Amendment 3," Florida Phoenix, August 3, 2026.
- "First responders sound the alarm over Florida's property tax proposal," WUSF, August 3, 2026.
- "Florida releases court-ordered rewrite of Amendment 3 ballot language," Local 10, August 13, 2026.
- "Florida 2026 races: GOP holds single-digit leads in new poll," Yahoo News / UNF PORL, March 2026.
