A Florida Man Tried to Kill His Ex Wife’s Best Friend With a Greeting Card and Peanut Butter

Nov 18, 2026

A Florida man knew his wife’s best friend could die from touching peanut butter.

He planned the murder for years  – drove to a different city, wore sunglasses inside the post office, and used a fake return address.

But aggravated battery was the best prosecutors could charge a Florida man who tried to kill his ex-wife’s best friend with a greeting card and peanut butter.

The Plan Was Cold-Blooded and Methodical

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, didn't snap in a moment of rage.

His divorce from his wife had been bitter, and he blamed her best friend – a woman he'd known for two decades – for blowing up the marriage.

The last time the three of them were in the same room was July 2022, dividing property after the divorce was finalized.

Three years passed.

Cancellare stewed.

Witnesses told investigators he'd made multiple remarks expressing a desire to harm people connected to the split.

He'd watched his target navigate restaurant menus and social gatherings for 20 years, taking careful precautions because her peanut allergy was so severe that breathing air near peanuts could send her into anaphylactic shock.

He knew exactly what peanut butter would do to her.

He chose it anyway.

The Catch Was Almost Accidental

What Cancellare didn't account for is that the USPS self-service kiosk he used photographed him during the transaction and embedded a 15-digit tracking code on every stamp he purchased.

Plantation police contacted a U.S. postal inspector, who traced that code to a specific machine at the Davie Post Office on South University Drive.

The transaction had been paid with a Visa card.

The card belonged to Joseph Cancellare.

When investigators showed the kiosk photograph to the victim, she identified him immediately.

One of his former bandmates and several other acquaintances confirmed the identification.

The envelope arrived at her home on August 14, 2025.

She noticed it looked greasy before she even opened it.

The handwriting was unfamiliar, and it had been addressed to an old residence she no longer used.

She opened it anyway – and found the card's interior smeared with a brown substance she recognized instantly.

She discarded the envelope, scrubbed her hands, and called for help.

It wasn't fast enough.

Hives erupted on both arms.

A tingling sensation lasted six hours.

She got lucky.

Here Is What Charges Were Actually Filed

Cancellare was arrested November 13, 2026 – more than 15 months after he mailed what investigators called a deliberate attempt to cause death or serious bodily injury.

He faces one count of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and one count of culpable negligence.

The aggravated battery charge is a second-degree felony in Florida carrying up to 15 years.

The culpable negligence charge carries a maximum of 60 days and a $500 fine.

Here's the problem.

Aggravated battery with a deadly weapon in Florida is the same charge you face for hitting someone with a baseball bat or throwing a brick through a car window.

It's the charge designed for spontaneous violent acts – not for a man who spent three years plotting to kill a specific woman using the one substance he knew her immune system couldn't survive.

There is no "attempted murder by biological weapon" charge in Florida's standard code.

There is no "premeditated use of a known allergen as a lethal agent" statute.

So what should by any reasonable standard be prosecuted as attempted murder – complete with premeditation, concealment of identity, a fake return address, and deliberate selection of a substance known to be lethal to the target – gets filed as the same category of crime as a bar fight that went too far.

The System Built This Gap and People Like Cancellare Walk Through It

This isn't a prosecutor's failure.

It's a legislative one.

Florida's criminal code was not built for the era of weaponized food allergies, targeted biological exposure, or premeditated attacks designed to look like accidents.

The law has a hole in it large enough to drive a greeting card through.

If she had opened that envelope without recognizing what was on it – touched the substance, gotten it near her face before she understood what was happening – she would have gone into anaphylaxis alone in her house.

There would have been no crime scene.

No murder weapon.

No Joseph Cancellare.

Just a woman who died of an allergy attack.

The detectives spent 15 months building a case meticulous enough to actually stick – and they did their jobs.

The charge they filed is the best available tool in Florida's current legal arsenal.

That tool isn't sharp enough for what Cancellare actually did.


Sources:

  • Sergio Candido, "Florida man accused of mailing peanut butter-covered card to woman with deadly allergy, police say," CBS Miami, November 14, 2026.
  • Plantation Police Department Probable Cause Affidavit, State v. Cancellare, November 2026.
  • Florida Statutes § 784.045, Aggravated Battery with a Deadly Weapon.

Latest Posts: