A Florida judge told Newell Walls to stay away from her ex-boyfriend's house.
She ignored the judge’s order.
And the Belle Isle Police arrested one Florida woman three times before she showed up with the gasoline.
She Stood There Watching It Burn
Walls, 41, had been in a seven-year relationship with the homeowner on Stockbridge Avenue in Belle Isle.
That relationship ended in a restraining order.
In November 2025, she trespassed at his home and got arrested.
She pleaded no contest, got sentenced to time served, and walked out of court with a no-contact order.
Eleven days before Tuesday night's fire, police trespassed her from the property again.
She came back anyway.
According to the Belle Isle police affidavit, the homeowner said Walls began “screaming nonsense” at him.
She then started “pouring gas onto everything in the carport and lighting it.”
She soaked the carport.
https://twitter.com/news6wkmg/status/2110400284803363114?s=20
She had already burned paper inside the house.
Then she put the whole thing to the torch.
Orange County Fire Rescue crews showed up and put out the flames.
Officers found Walls hiding under the carport of a vacant home nearby – treated for burns on her hands and feet.
The homeowner, who had been trying to offer her a place to stay when the fire broke out, told WKMG the fire severely damaged his home and his business.
He said he's trying to recover.
Three Court Interventions and She Still Came Back
This is not a unique story.
It happens over and over in this country because judges hand out no-contact orders like parking tickets and expect dangerous people to honor them.
They don't.
In 2023, a man in Cobb County, Georgia violated his no-contact order and set a car on fire outside his girlfriend's mother's home – the fire spread, killed two women inside, and he got two life sentences.
"This community was robbed of two amazing women who opened their home as a refuge," said Senior Assistant District Attorney Jared Horowitz. "These two mothers did what any parent would—protect their children from an abuser. But this defendant used fire to seek revenge. Justice prevailed today, and his reign of terror is finally over."
In 2025, a man in North Carolina was arrested twice in 24 hours – first for arson, then immediately for violating the domestic violence protection order that had just been served on him while he was in custody for the arson.
In Washington, D.C., a man sentenced to 19.5 years in federal prison set his ex-girlfriend's apartment building on fire after ignoring multiple orders to stay away.
The pattern is always the same.
A court issues an order.
A dangerous person ignores the order.
The court issues another order.
The dangerous person escalates.
Newell Walls had already been arrested at this address.
She had already pleaded no contest.
She had already received a no-contact order and was also trespassed from the property before she showed up with gasoline.
That's three separate chances the system had to take this seriously.
The Homeowner Got Lucky
There was a person inside the house when Walls lit it on fire.
Newell Elizabeth Walls “allegedly used gasoline and a lighter to intentionally set the residence on fire following a dispute with the homeowner.”
Arson of an occupied dwelling – that's the charge.
She is being held without bond at the Orange County Jail.
No-contact orders work exactly as well as the people they're issued against choose to let them work.
In this case, the homeowner survived.
In Cobb County, they didn't.
The courts keep writing orders and hoping dangerous people obey them.
Newell Walls couldn't have been clearer about what that order was worth to her.
Sources:
- Cristóbal Reyes, "Woman sets Belle Isle house ablaze after being told to stay away, police say," Orlando Sentinel, October 14, 2026.
- Allison Petro, "Woman accused of using gasoline to set Orange County home on fire with person inside, police say," WKMG News 6, October 14, 2026.
- James Tutten, "Woman used gasoline to set Belle Isle home on fire after dispute, police say," WFTV, October 14, 2026.
- "Man found guilty of setting house fire that killed girlfriend's family," Cobb County Courier, February 2025.
- "Unionville Man Arrested Twice in 24 Hours for Arson and Protection Order Violation," Union County Sheriff's Office, May 2, 2025.
