Florida homeowners watched their property tax bills explode for five straight years.
County governments called it a necessity.
But Ron DeSantis is pointing at sheriff's budgets that crossed a billion dollars and asking one question nobody wants to answer.
The Numbers County Governments Hope You Never See
Florida's local governments collected $31 billion in property taxes in 2019.
By 2024, that number had hit $55 billion.
That's $24 billion more – every single year – extracted from Florida homeowners while politicians told them there wasn't a dollar to spare.
DeSantis has spent over a year calling this situation exactly what it is: "paying rent to the government."
Now he's backing it up.
https://twitter.com/ReOpenChris/status/2100697274728817014?s=20
He pointed directly at Broward County's Sheriff's Office this week as exhibit A for why Amendment 3 opponents aren't being straight with voters.
"Look at how some of these Sheriff's Departments, like Broward, look where they were eight years ago versus their budget now," DeSantis said. "Budget's a billion dollars for a county Sheriff's Department."
He acknowledged law enforcement does good work – but made the point that Florida taxpayers needed someone to make.
There may be things in there, he said, that are "nice to have rather than need to have."
He's right.
Palm Beach County's Sheriff's budget has crossed $1 billion.
Miami-Dade's has too.
These are county-level law enforcement agencies with ten-figure budgets, funded by the same homeowners who've watched their tax bills nearly double in five years.
Why Every First Responder Group in Florida Is Fighting This
The Florida Sheriffs Association is running ads claiming Amendment 3 "rips out Florida's biggest source of public safety funding with no plan to replace it."
Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd – a DeSantis ally and frequent presence at his press conferences – called the amendment a "train wreck" that "defunds" police and fire.
The Fraternal Order of Police says public safety "should never become collateral damage."
The Professional Firefighters are against it.
The Fire Chiefs Association is against it.
Every. Single. One.
https://twitter.com/GovRonDeSantis/status/2099555567744282684?s=20
And that tells you something important – not about Amendment 3, but about what happens when government agencies get used to a revenue stream and someone threatens to turn it off.
When Florida property values spiked and tax bills followed, county governments didn't send the surplus back.
They spent it.
And now that a constitutional amendment might force them to live on less, the agencies that depend on that money are calling it an emergency.
That's not a public safety argument.
That's a budget protection argument.
DeSantis Is Doing What Republicans Almost Never Do
DeSantis built his political identity on being the most pro-law enforcement governor in America.
Since 2022, his administration has paid out more than $83 million recruiting roughly 12,500 officers to Florida – many of them cops who left blue states where Democrats were busy defunding them.
His brand was built on standing with the badge.
And he's still standing with it.
He's not attacking law enforcement.
He's attacking bloated government budgets that happen to have law enforcement on the letterhead.
That distinction matters because Republicans almost never make it.
The standard move is to fund whatever a sheriff's association asks for, wave the flag, and call yourself pro-cop.
DeSantis is doing something harder – telling Florida's most politically connected government agencies that when revenue drops, they find efficiencies, just like every Florida family had to when their own budgets got squeezed by the tax bills funding those agencies.
Amendment 3 would raise the homestead exemption from $50,000 to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028 – saving the average Florida homeowner $1,500 to $2,000 next year and $3,000 to $3,500 the year after.
Florida Realtors just dropped $10 million to pass it.
DeSantis is now actively campaigning for it.
The sheriffs have a choice: find the fat DeSantis is talking about, or make the case to Florida voters that these budgets have nothing left to cut.
That's a case they're going to have a very hard time making.
Sources:
- A.G. Gancarski, "Ron DeSantis says Sheriffs have room to cut their budgets if Amendment 3 passes," Florida Politics, September 17, 2026.
- "Florida Sheriffs Association is 'significantly concerned' about Amendment 3," Florida Phoenix, August 3, 2026.
- "First responders sound the alarm over Florida's property tax proposal," WFSU News, August 3, 2026.
- "Florida Property Tax Amendment: Ballot Language Summary," Florida Policy Institute, 2026.
- "Florida Realtors put $10M toward passing property tax proposal," Tampa Bay Times, September 10, 2026.
