Fort Myers and Key West tried it.
Both caved within days.
Now Tallahassee thinks it can walk away from its ICE partnership – and Florida's Attorney General just told them exactly what happened to the last two cities that tried.
Uthmeier Has Done This Before and Won Every Time
Attorney General James Uthmeier dropped a legal opinion on Wednesday warning that any city terminating an existing 287(g) agreement with ICE – without iron-clad justification – would likely violate Florida's ban on sanctuary policies.
The opinion landed first in Doral, where Mayor Christi Fraga had asked Uthmeier whether her city could legally exit its ICE partnership.
Deputy Attorney General Greg Slemp's answer drew a critical line.
Cities that never signed a 287(g) agreement aren't automatically in violation of Florida law.
https://twitter.com/EricLDaugh/status/2120638278387032188?a=qmT1hQ9rS8ZOZDT-8sI&s=20
But cities that already signed one – like Doral and Tallahassee – face a much harder legal reality.
Slemp's conclusion: walking away from an existing agreement without hard justification signals the city isn't making its "best efforts" to support federal immigration enforcement – the precise standard Florida Statute 908.104 demands.
"Supporting our federal partners and protecting our sovereignty isn't optional, it's the law," Uthmeier posted on X after releasing the opinion.
Uthmeier then aimed the same warning at Tallahassee, where city commissioners had just voted unanimously to put their ICE agreement up for review.
That vote didn't terminate anything – it just put the question on the agenda.
Uthmeier didn't wait for a future agenda.
Byron Donalds Is Coming In January
The timing matters for more than just Tallahassee and Doral.
Governor-elect Byron Donalds responded to the Tallahassee vote with a direct warning: "Florida is not a sanctuary state, and as Governor, I will never let it become one. Florida cities must comply with federal and state laws – full stop."
Donalds spent the 2026 campaign promising to remove local officials who established sanctuary policies – and he's made clear he intends to follow DeSantis' playbook of treating Uthmeier's legal opinions as the opening move, not the last one.
The pattern is now well-established across Florida.
In March 2025, the Fort Myers City Council deadlocked 3-3 on its ICE agreement.
Uthmeier sent a letter warning council members they faced potential removal from office by the governor.
The council reversed and approved the agreement unanimously.
https://twitter.com/KennedyFaith__/status/2123553288092025303?a=xOOANs3iHQ_7eGMe1Vo&s=20
Three months later, Key West commissioners voted 6-1 to void their existing ICE partnership.
Uthmeier declared Key West had made itself a sanctuary city and sent letters threatening removal.
Within days, commissioners – including the mayor who originally voted to void the agreement – reversed course and re-entered the partnership.
Commissioner Donald Lee said it plainly: "I'm voting with my head and not my heart."
What the Doral Situation Reveals About the Bigger Fight
Doral adds a layer of complexity the Tallahassee situation doesn't have.
The city has a large Venezuelan and Cuban immigrant population – exactly the communities that federal immigration enforcement has hit hardest over the past 18 months.
The city approved its 287(g) participation in April 2025 and formalized the agreement in January 2026 – and not a single Doral officer has been trained under the program yet.
Doral Councilwoman Maureen Porras, who supports ending the agreement, tried to bring it to a vote Wednesday.
She got no second.
Vice Mayor Rafael Pineyro moved to wait for the attorney general's opinion first – which is exactly what arrived the next day telling them what they already knew was coming.
Federal ICE agents operate in Doral with or without the 287(g) agreement – tearing up a piece of paper doesn't move a single agent.
What Uthmeier's opinion does is shut down the performative gesture of exiting the agreement while leaving every practical reality unchanged.
Florida Has Now Flipped 97 of 140 National ICE Agreements and Donalds Wants the Rest
Florida now has 97 of the nation's 140 active 287(g) agreements – by far the largest share of any state.
That didn't happen by accident.
It happened because DeSantis and Uthmeier built a legal architecture – Florida Statute 908.103 banning sanctuary policies, 908.104 requiring "best efforts" to support federal enforcement – and then enforced it with the credible threat of removal from office.
https://twitter.com/news6wkmg/status/2123431145241006370?a=GznXyszslvF9wPRHBM0&s=20
Every city that tested that threat backed down.
Tallahassee's commission may believe it's different because it's the state capital – that the political optics of the governor going after the capital city will create too much backlash.
They're miscalculating.
Donalds takes office in January with Trump's endorsement, a mandate built on immigration enforcement, and a pattern of winning every single one of these confrontations.
Commissioner Dianne Williams-Cox already warned her colleagues about the potential penalties they face.
Tallahassee Mayor Jeremy Matlow's argument – that state law didn't explicitly require his city to sign the agreement – is legally contested and politically irrelevant.
Uthmeier's opinion doesn't need to be right to be effective.
Fort Myers found that out in March.
Key West found that out in July.
Tallahassee is next.
Sources:
- Kennedy Owens, "Uthmeier warns of legal consequences as Tallahassee considers ending police partnership with ICE," Florida's Voice, November 19, 2026.
- "Florida tourist hotspot nearly becomes sanctuary city before leaders reverse ICE policy," Fox News, July 2025.
- "Reversing course, Key West commissioners agree to cooperate with ICE agreement," Yahoo News, July 2025.
- "After state's threats, a Florida city reverses course on immigration enforcement vote," Yahoo News, March 2025.









